Abstract of

The First R Yesterday and Today: U.S. Elementary Reading Instruction Practices Reported by Teachers and Administrators

James F. Baumann

James V. Hoffman

Ann M. Duffy-Hester

Jennifer Moon Ro

This study was a modified replication of Austin and Morrison's classic 1963 study of the status of U.S. public school elementary reading instruction, The First R: The Harvard Report on Reading in Elementary Schools. Surveys modeled after those used in The First R were distributed to a national sample of elementary classroom teachers, building administrators, and district administrators. Results reveal some similarities between reading instruction in the 1960s and today. Teachers of today and yesterday both (a) work with self-contained, heterogeneously assigned classes; (b) dedicate significant time for reading instruction; (c) provide explicit instruction in phonic analysis; (d) are not overly satisfied with their preservice training in reading instruction; (e) administer mandated standardized tests; and (f) report accommodating struggling or underachieving readers as their greatest challenge. Important differences are also noted. Teachers today have more professional training than peers of the past, and they adopt a balanced, eclectic perspective, in contrast to a strong skillsbased emphasis in the past. The three-group reading plan has been replaced by considerable whole-class instruction, and programs using both basals and trade books are the norm now compared to the exclusive reliance on basals in the 1960s. An emergent literacy perspective has replaced a reading readiness view, synthetic phonics has supplanted analytic phonics, and alternative reading assessments are in regular use today. School and classroom libraries in the 1990s are more prevalent and better equipped, and changes in programs and philosophy are common today, unlike the static state of reading instruction in the 1960s.

Abstract from Baumann, J.F., Hoffman, J.V., Duffy-Hester, A.M., & Ro, J. (2000). The First R Yesterday and Today: U.S. Elementary Reading Instruction Practices Reported by Teachers and Administrators. Reading Research Quarterly, 35(3), 338–377. doi: 10.1598/RRQ.35.3.2